'What Are We Going To Do?': Towns Reel As Banks Close Branches At Record Pace | New Hampshire Public Radio

'What Are We Going To Do?': Towns Reel As Banks Close Branches At Record Pace

Mar 26, 2021
Originally published on March 29, 2021 2:46 am

Updated March 26, 2021 at 11:29 AM ET

Updated at 11:29 a.m.

George Holland, the mayor of Moorhead, Miss., remembers the feeling when he heard that Regions Bank was closing its branch in his small, rural town a few years ago.

"That was actually the only bank in our community and the next-closest bank was probably 8, 9 miles to Indianola," Holland said. "I was thinking, 'What are we going to do?' "

Banks have been permanently shuttering branches for years, but the number of closures hit a record in 2020 as the pandemic accelerated the move by many customers to online banking.

Banks closed 3,324 branches last year, according to a tally by S&P Global Market Intelligence.

It makes financial sense for banks given the cost of operating branches.

"The reality is, the vast majority of the activity that happens in a branch is not revenue generating," said Steven Reider, who as president of the consulting firm Bancography advises banks on branch locations. "In fact, it's cost-carrying activity."

And bank branch closures are especially affecting isolated neighborhoods in big cities or towns like Moorhead — a largely African American community in the heart of the Mississippi Delta.

Research by the National Community Reinvestment Coalition shows that poor communities, rural communities and areas with a high concentration of Black and brown residents have been hardest hit.

Part of the reason is that regulators cracked down on costly overdraft fees a decade ago, making it less profitable for many banks to operate branches in those communities.

"It's a good thing that banks are moving away from charging those kinds of fees, but it's a bad thing that they're moving away from serving those neighborhoods," said Jesse Van Tol, NCRC's CEO.

When banks close, the impact can go beyond inconvenience. It can also push people to more expensive options such as check-cashing stores or payday lenders.

"Lower-income consumers don't necessarily have automobiles," said Reider. "They don't have a lot of choices. And then, of course, those payday lenders come in and that just perpetuates a cycle of low income because consumers spend inordinate amounts just managing their financial services."

It's a trend that's unlikely to reverse now that the pandemic has pushed more customers to bank on smartphones and computers.

As banks close, many communities have been looking to nonprofit credit unions and other alternatives to fill the void.

"In the last 60 days, I've had two mayors reach out to me saying, 'Would you bring a bank branch here?' " says Darrin Williams, CEO of Southern Bancorp, which specializes in underserved communities.

Williams understands that for small towns a bank can be more than a place to cash a check. It can also be the place to catch up or gossip about what's going on around town.

"In a lot of the rural communities we serve, the bank branch is part of the social fabric," Williams said. "If you go to Truman, Ark., on a payday Friday, there are going to be 10 people deep in the line. People want to come to that bank branch because it's social."

Even though a lot of banking can now be done online, an FDIC survey found that 83% of people still met with a teller or other bank employee at least once during 2019. That same year, more than 40% of rural customers made at least 10 visits to the bank.

Luckily for Moorhead, when Regions Bank pulled out, a nonprofit credit union came in.

Regions donated the branch building to Hope Credit Union, and provided funding for transition costs. Mayor Holland says it's actually been an improvement. The credit union signed up more customers, offers more services and even added an ATM — something the old bank didn't have.

"I can't say enough about what that meant to us to be able to bank right here in our town," Holland said. "To be able to have all these resources right here in our town without having to travel."

But not all towns or neighborhoods are lucky.

Steven Jackson, a parish commissioner in Shreveport, La., is watching the closures with alarm.

"A lot of banks have utilized the pandemic to justify downsizing even more," Jackson says.

And he worries about what that does to neighborhoods and towns like his.

"When you have young boys and girls riding by and seeing empty buildings, or that building which was once a bank is turned over to a payday lender, what message are we sending?" he asks. "Is my neighborhood not a priority?"

Clarification: 3/25/21

Updates story to note that when Regions Bank closed its branch in Moorhead, Miss., the bank donated its building to Hope Credit Union's parent company and provided funding to facilitate a smooth transition.

Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

The pandemic drove record numbers of bank branches to close. It's part of a years-long trend toward online banking. But people who need a local physical branch may find nothing. Just as some places are food deserts, neighborhoods with no groceries, NPR's Scott Horsley reports on the risk of bank deserts.

SCOTT HORSLEY, BYLINE: Moorhead, Miss., is a town of under 2,000 people in the heart of the Delta. It was once an important commercial crossroads where the Southern Railroad met the Yazoo Delta line, a junction memorialized in W.C. Handy's "Yellow Dog Blues."

(SOUNDBITE OF BEN'S BAD BOYS' "YELLOW DOG BLUES")

HORSLEY: Moorhead is still an important tourist stop on the Mississippi blues trail, but its commercial clout has declined over the decades. Mayor George Holland says the local bank branch pulled up stakes a few years ago.

(SOUNDBITE OF BEN'S BAD BOYS' "YELLOW DOG BLUES")

GEORGE HOLLAND: When I heard that Regions Bank was moving out, I'm thinking, what are we going to do? That was actually the only bank in our community. And the next closest bank was probably 8, 9 miles to Indianola.

HORSLEY: That's a minor inconvenience if you have a car, but a real hardship for those who don't. More communities are wrestling with that as banks permanently closed a record 3,300 branches last year. U.S. Bancorp closed about a quarter of its branches. CEO Andrew Cecere told financial analysts, thanks to the pandemic, more of his customers have switched to banking on smartphones and computers.

ANDREW CECERE: Seventy-seven percent of our customers are using the digital channel. So there's a behavior change that's accelerated as a result of the pandemic, and the closures reflect that.

HORSLEY: But it's not just about consumer choice. Bank branches are expensive, so banks can save money by pushing customers online. Steven Jackson, who's a parish commissioner in Shreveport, La., worries that's turning parts of his city into banking deserts.

STEVEN JACKSON: A lot of banking institutions have utilized the pandemic to go ahead and justify downsizing even more. What we were seeing is, disproportionately, branches were being closed in communities of color.

HORSLEY: That could make it harder for small businesses in those neighborhoods to get a loan or cash to make change for their own customers. And when there's no convenient bank nearby, people often have to turn to more expensive options, like check cashing stores and payday lenders.

JACKSON: When you have young boys and girls riding by seeing empty buildings or that building which was once a bank is now turned over to a payday lender, what message are we sending? Is my neighborhood not a priority?

HORSLEY: Even though a lot of banking can be done online now, an FDIC survey found 83% of people still met with a teller or other bank employee at least once during 2019. That same year, more than 40% of rural customers made at least 10 visits to the bank. That's why, as banks close their doors, many communities have been looking to nonprofit credit unions and other alternatives to help fill the void. Darrin Williams, the CEO of Southern Bancorp, says he hears regularly from people in bank deserts who want him to open a branch. Half a dozen of the branches he operates are the only bank in town.

DARRIN WILLIAMS: In a lot of the rural communities we serve, the bank branch is part of the social fabric. So if you go to Trumann, Ark., on a payday Friday, there are going to be 10 people deep in the line.

HORSLEY: Moorhead, Miss., got lucky. When Regions Bank pulled out in 2015, Hope Credit Union came in. Mayor Holland says the credit union signed up more customers, offers more services and even added an ATM, something the old bank never did.

HOLLAND: I can't say enough about what that meant to us - to be able to bank right here in our town, to be able to have all of these resources right here in our town without having to travel.

HORSLEY: That kind of alternative will be increasingly important as more bank branches close. Otherwise, more communities will be singing the bank desert blues.

Scott Horsley, NPR News, Washington.

(SOUNDBITE OF BEN'S BAD BOYS' "YELLOW DOG BLUES") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.