An Apple Detective Rediscovered 7 Kinds Of Apples Thought To Be Extinct | New Hampshire Public Radio

An Apple Detective Rediscovered 7 Kinds Of Apples Thought To Be Extinct

Jun 11, 2021
Originally published on June 11, 2021 11:12 pm

Updated June 11, 2021 at 5:39 PM ET

David Benscoter was a criminal investigator at the FBI and IRS for 24 years before transitioning to his new role: apple detective.

He's the founder of the Lost Apple Project, a nonprofit organization that searches abandoned farms and orchards in the Pacific Northwest to locate old varieties. Benscoter recently found seven types of apples in old orchards in Oregon, Washington and Idaho that were thought to have gone extinct as long as a century ago.

They're a mix of red, green and yellow, with names like the Almota, the Ivanhoe, the Eper and the Iowa Flat. Since 2014, Benscoter's organization has discovered 29 lost apple varieties, including the Streaked Pippin, the Sary Sinap and the Nero.

Dave Benscoter rediscovered the Iowa Flat and other apples by finding watercolor paintings like this commissioned by the USDA.
U.S. Department of Agriculture

"An apple tree you've never tasted before, a taste somebody hasn't tasted in a hundred years, it's rewarding knowing that we brought these varieties back," Benscoter said.

Benscoter became interested in apples after a neighbor with a disability asked him to help care for her apple trees.

There were once at least 17,000 named varieties of apples in North America, but only about 4,500 are known to exist today. By the 20th century, farmers stopped growing most apple types because they were less in demand.

Benscoter scours seed catalogues, county fair records, newspaper clippings and nursery sales ledgers to search for lost apples. He found one, for instance, in a watercolor painting of fruits and nuts that the USDA contracted in 1880.

He says the 100-year wait was worth it. The rediscovered apples, he says, have a unique taste compared to regular varieties, but are still just as tasty. According to the Whitman County Historical Society, which partnered with the nonprofit on the project, rediscovered apple types will soon become available again to the public.

Apple detective Dave Benscoter works out in the field to search for apples thought to be extinct.
Dave Benscoter

"We get excited when they make discoveries," said USDA apple curator Ben Gutierrez, who has collaborated with Benscoter. "Because it's a push for Apple conservationism."

Gutierrez said the rediscoveries are a step toward increased genetic diversity of apples. He can test the historic varieties to find out what farmers and buyers will want. The USDA can then piece together that information to help farmers more reliably grow apples, not use as much pesticides and increase nutritional quality.

Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit


Dave Benscoter is a retired criminal investigator who lives in Washington state.

DAVE BENSCOTER: For 24 years, I was in federal law enforcement.

KING: He has worked for the FBI and the IRS. These days, though, Benscoter calls himself a fruit detective.

BENSCOTER: I search for lost and rare apples.


He is the founder of the Lost Apple Project. It recently helped find seven types of apples that were thought to be extinct. They were rediscovered in old orchards in Washington, Oregon and Idaho. They taste great, we hear, and have great names like the Ivanhoe, the Iowa Flat and the Steptoe.

BENSCOTER: Today, there are at least 17,000 named varieties of apples in North America.

KING: Before the 20th century, there used to be a lot more varieties. But Benscoter says a lot of those apples were what he calls spitters.

BENSCOTER: You bite into them, and you want to just spit it out as quickly as you can.

MCCAMMON: So farmers stopped growing them because people wanted tastier apples. But there are still records of the extinct apples in seed catalogs and county fair records.

KING: And other interesting places. One of the apples that Benscoter found is called the Kay. He first saw it in a watercolor painting.

BENSCOTER: The U.S. Department of Agriculture back in 1880 contracted with a bunch of watercolor artists to paint fruits and nuts.

MCCAMMON: Benscoter came across a tree that he estimates was about 130 years old. He picked a red, tart-tasting Apple that the Oregon-based Temperate Orchard Conservancy identified as a Kay.

BENSCOTER: You know, an apple tree you've never tasted before, a taste somebody hasn't tasted in a hundred years. It's rewarding knowing that we've brought these varieties back.

KING: More rewarding than working for the IRS? OK, yeah, I see it. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.