Sunday was supposed to be the final deadline to enroll in health coverage for 2020 on HealthCare.gov, the federal marketplace for buying individual health insurance. But website glitches — that may have caused enrollment problems — prompted an outcry, and the government restarted enrollment Monday.
The new deadline is Wednesday, Dec. 18, at 3 a.m. ET. Consumers who already have an account can shop for plans and find out whether they qualify for subsidies to lower the costs of plans at HealthCare.gov. (Twelve states and the District of Columbia have their own health insurance exchanges — and their enrollment deadlines vary.)
The person who appears to have flagged the technical issue first was Joshua Peck. He worked on HealthCare.gov outreach at the Center for Medicare & Medicaid Services under President Barack Obama. In 2017, when the Trump administration slashed the outreach and advertising budget for HealthCare.gov, Peck founded the nonprofit Get America Covered to do some of that work outside the government.
https://t.co/vukmhBMkkk is not letting people login to enroll. This is the second outage, the first lasted 15 minutes. We're 8 minutes into the second. Last time this happened, 100k people could not enroll. @CMSGov must extend the deadline. pic.twitter.com/6VJYNwsoL9— Joshua Peck (@JoshuaFAPeck) December 15, 2019
"On Sunday, I received an alert that told me that there may be an issue on the site," Peck says. He went to the login page and got an error message. "It didn't tell people the system was having a problem; it didn't tell people to wait on the site and try again," he says. "It was incredibly confusing."
He shared the message on Twitter and called on CMS to extend the deadline.
Midday Monday, CMS Administrator Seema Verma seemed to have heeded the call.
In an abundance of caution, to accommodate consumers who during the final hours of Open Enrollment may have experienced issues, starting at 3 pm ET today, we are extending the deadline to sign up for January 1 coverage until 3 am ET December 18. https://t.co/zNNxtNoAMb— Administrator Seema Verma (@SeemaCMS) December 16, 2019
CMS did not respond to NPR's request for details about the decision or for an estimate of how many people may have been affected by the website problems.
Charles Gaba, an analyst who tracks enrollment in Affordable Care Act exchanges, has a guess as to how many people may have had problems signing up on Sunday.
"I'd estimate that it'll be somewhere in the range of around 100,000 people," he says. He notes 36 hours is not a lot of time to let those people know they still have a chance to sign up for coverage in 2020. But "it's better than nothing," he says.
This is not the first time website troubles have kept people from signing up. HealthCare.gov had a famously rocky start in 2013. Even this year, the first day of open enrollment, Nov. 1, had problems. Peck estimated around 100,000 people may have missed out on coverage because of those issues.
Overall, enrollment seems to be down a bit from last year, a trend that has continued since 2016. President Trump has tried to change — critics would say undermine — the health exchanges in a variety of ways, but they have proved to be quite resilient.
Still, 27.5 million people are uninsured, according to the Census Bureau. A Kaiser Family Foundation analysis found that 4.7 million of them would be eligible for health care plans with zero dollar monthly premiums after subsidies.
The new deadline means a busy extra 36 hours for "navigators," who help people through the enrollment process free of charge.
Melanie Hall is a navigator and the executive director of the Family Health Care Foundation in the Tampa Bay area. She says the issues on Sunday didn't faze her — she just kept refreshing the page until she was able to get people enrolled. But she is glad there's another chance for consumers who might have been thrown off by the last-minute technical issues.
"For anybody that's calling in a panic today or tomorrow, we will have the availability to still make sure that they get enrolled if that's what they choose to do," Hall says.
She has already called back several panicked people to help them finish signing up.
DAVID GREENE, HOST:
Open enrollment on healthcare.gov is back. This is the federal health insurance exchange set up by the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare. Sunday was supposed to be the final deadline for coverage in 2020, but website glitches prompted an outcry, and the government restarted enrollment for 36 hours. NPR's Selena Simmons-Duffin has the story.
SELENA SIMMONS-DUFFIN, BYLINE: On Sunday afternoon, Joshua Peck got an alert that healthcare.gov might be in trouble.
JOSHUA PECK: I received an alert that told me that there may be an issue on the site.
SIMMONS-DUFFIN: Who is this person who monitors the health exchange website? Well, under President Obama, he worked in the federal agency that runs it, the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services. His job was to get the word out about the exchanges. In 2017, the Trump administration slashed that budget. So Peck set up an organization called Get America Covered to do that work outside of the government. When he got the alert, knowing that a lot of people wait until the last minute to enroll, he got worried.
PECK: I went to the log-in page and saw the error message that people were getting. And that's initially what I posted on Twitter.
SIMMONS-DUFFIN: A lot of high-profile Democrats retweeted him, including presidential candidates Elizabeth Warren, Pete Buttigieg and Joe Biden. Many called on CMS administrators Seema Verma to extend the deadline so that people getting the error messages could still sign up. Midday Monday, she seemed to heed the call and announced healthcare.gov would reopen enrollment. Charles Gaba is an analyst who tracks healthcare.gov enrollment. He has a guess for how many people might have missed out because of the glitches.
CHARLES GABA: I'd estimate that it'd be somewhere in the range of around 100,000 people.
SIMMONS-DUFFIN: There's no guarantee all of those people will hear about the new deadline. And there are many more people with no health coverage at all - 27 million. The Kaiser Family Foundation estimates about 5 million of them are eligible for plans on healthcare.gov with $0 monthly premiums after subsidies. The new deadline for enrolling in coverage is December 18 at 3 a.m. Eastern. Selena Simmons-Duffin, NPR News.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC) Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.